Should You Hire a Career Coach? [The Pros & Cons in 2024]

4 April
9 min read
Background Image

Should You Hire a Career Coach? [The Pros & Cons in 2024]

Your career isn’t shaping up to what you thought it would.

You haven’t made progress in a while, and you’re starting to wonder if you ever will. It’s time to face it – you're in a slump.

Thankfully, there are experts out there whose job it is to bail you out of that career standstill.

Career coaches are increasingly popular among professionals looking to meet their career goals sooner rather than later, and they might be worth giving a try.

In this article, we’re going to cover:

  • What a Career Coach Is
  • When You Should Hire a Career Coach
  • Tips to Choose the Best Career Coach

… and more!

Let’s dive in.

What Is a Career Coach?

A career coach is a professional dedicated to helping people navigate their career paths, whether they're starting, looking to advance, or considering a change in direction.

Career coaches offer personalized advice and strategies based on your skills, interests, and goals. They work with you through one-on-one sessions to identify your strengths and weaknesses, develop professional goals, and create actionable plans to achieve them.

Career coaches can help you make your resume, prepare for job interviews, share networking tips and strategies, and teach you how to negotiate job offers and salaries.

They also offer support and accountability, which can help you stay focused and motivated throughout your job hunt.

Their expertise and outsider perspective can be invaluable in helping you make informed decisions about your career trajectory, overcome obstacles, and ultimately reach your professional objectives.

Should You Hire a Career Coach?

If you’re contemplating hiring a career coach, you’re probably at a crossroads in your career.

Whatever your circumstances are, a career coach can provide personalized guidance and strategies to navigate the challenges you’re facing.

Career coaches offer a blend of mentorship, professional development, and accountability that's tailored to your specific goals and desired industry.

So, if you’re ready for an outside perspective on your professional journey, it might be time to invest in the expertise of a career coach.

Pros vs. Cons

Career coaches aren’t the answer to every problem you have. As with any other type of counseling, career coaching comes with pros and cons you should consider.

  • Valuable insight. The right career coach will have all the experience necessary to take you to the next level of your career. Whether you want to land your dream job, secure a promotion, or even branch off on your own, a career coach could be your key to success.
  • Faster job hunting. Since career coaches are HR industry experts, they know the ins and outs of job applications, and they can help you avoid mistakes on your job hunt. You’re also likely to get results much faster than if you do everything on your own.
  • Increased accountability. It’s tough to keep track of your goals or stay motivated on your own; having someone hold you accountable can be a game changer. Career coaches can provide you with their full attention and help keep you on track, even on your bad days.
  • Expensive cost. Career coaches don’t come cheap. Paying an hourly rate of over $70 on average might be an investment in your future, but it isn’t an option for everyone.
  • False advertising. There are plenty of stellar career coaches out there, but there are also scammers. If you’re not careful when choosing your career coach, you might end up picking the wrong one and wasting your money on poor advice.

When to Consider a Career Coach

Certain obstacles on your career journey might need help to get past them.

Here are a few situations when you should consider hiring a career coach:

#1. You’re Confused

If you’re feeling confused about your career path, it’s a clear sign that it might be time to consider hiring a career coach.

When you're not sure what steps to take next or how to move forward in your career, a career coach can provide the clarity and direction you need.

Career coaches can help you identify your strengths, passions, and potential career options that align with your personal and professional goals. With their guidance, you can explore new possibilities, make informed decisions, and develop a strategic plan to achieve your ambitions.

Partnering up with a career coach can be the catalyst you need to move from confusion to confidence and set you on a path to a fulfilling career.

#2. You’re Stuck

You feel like your career has hit a wall.

It’s been a while since you’ve been at your current job, and you’re not moving up the ladder. In other words - your career has stalled, and you’re not getting where you want to be.

This is where a career coach comes in. Someone who can offer an unbiased perspective on your situation can help you see opportunities and solutions that you couldn’t find on your own.

Career coaches specialize in identifying the root causes of whatever made your career stagnate. Whether it's a skill gap, a lack of networking, or a misalignment between your current role and your personal goals, a career coach can help you find a way past it.

The personalized guidance a career coach offers can get you out of your current standstill and also equip you with the tools and confidence to navigate any future career challenges on your own.

Feel like you’re underpaid? Learn the best strategy for getting a raise here.

#3. You’re In a Bad Place

Whether you were fired, spent ages in a stressful job, or lost confidence in your job search abilities, it’s a tough spot to be in.

Career coaches have the expertise to help you navigate through this challenging time. A coach can work with you to understand what went wrong, what’s holding you back, and how to improve your situation.

They offer strategies to deal with stress, frustration, and anxiety, which can help you regain your professional confidence. Together, you’ll create a plan that plays to your strengths and addresses any areas that need improvement.

The personalized support of a career coach can speed up your immediate job search and help you build resilience and the skills necessary to navigate future challenges.

#4. Your Job Search Seems Endless

If you’ve sent hundreds of resumes so far and you don’t have a single job offer to show for it, it might be time to find a career coach.

They can provide a fresh perspective on your job search strategy and help you pinpoint where you might be lacking.

Similar to a career writer, a career coach can help you tailor your resume and cover letter to best highlight your skills and experiences in a way that resonates with employers.

Additionally, career coaches can also help optimize your LinkedIn profile and teach you how to effectively leverage your network.

Since career coaches have insights into industry-specific hiring practices, they can coach you on how to stand out in a competitive job market. Their feedback and strategic advice can turn your job search frustrations into opportunities and make your application process more effective.

#5. You Want a Career Change

If you’re considering trying something you’ve never done before, it can be intimidating.

Here, a career coach can help you bridge the gap between where you are and where you want to be.

They know which of your transferable skills can help you and how you should convey them to potential employers in your new field. They’ll also help tailor your resume and cover letter to highlight experiences and achievements that align with the job you want.

Career coaches can identify any gaps in your skills and recommend ways for you to gain the needed qualifications before diving into your new career. Since they have insights into different fields, they might give you specialized career tips you won’t find anywhere else.

Finally, a career coach can also help you set realistic goals for your new career path, which will boost your confidence and make a potentially daunting career change feel less overwhelming.

#6. Interviews Are a Nightmare

It might be time to talk to a career coach if you find yourself consistently rejected after job interviews.

Whether you’re new to the job market or have decades of experience, interviews are nerve-wracking. It’s hard to communicate your skills and value under pressure, and even the best candidates don’t always present themselves in the best possible light.

A career coach can work with you to identify the gaps in your interview technique. They provide practical advice on how to answer the most common interview questions, how to articulate your achievements confidently, and how to make a memorable impression.

They can also offer feedback on your body language and help you project confidence and professionalism. Career coaches usually employ mock interviews and personalized feedback to help you build the skills and confidence needed to ace your interviews.

A career coach’s support can be the key to turning your interview experiences around and enabling you to present yourself as the competent and valuable candidate you are.

Think your last interview went well? Read our article to learn how to accept a job offer.

#7. You Can’t Expand Your Network

Networking is a crucial step to advancing in your career, but you might not know where to start.

Hiring a career coach can be a strategic move that helps you connect with the right people.

Career coaches can provide you with the tools and strategies to build and nurture a robust professional network. They can guide you on how to leverage social media platforms like LinkedIn, what industry-relevant events to attend, and how to engage in groups within your field.

A coach can further teach you how to make meaningful connections, including how to introduce yourself, how to follow up after initial contact, and how to offer value to your connections.

By developing a personalized networking strategy with you, a career coach helps you overcome barriers that will make it easier for you to reach out to industry professionals, discover hidden job opportunities, and gain insights into your field.

#8. Your Motivation Is Lacking

Staying on track to achieve your ultimate career goals is tough, no doubt about it.

Throughout your career, you’re going to get stuck, burn out, face all sorts of challenges, and possibly lose track of your goal down the line.

This is where the support of a career coach can be invaluable.

Career coaches work with you to find what drives you and what might be holding you back. Whether it's uncertainty about your career path, feeling overwhelmed by your goals, or a lack of confidence in your abilities, a career coach can help you figure things out.

By setting clear short-term goals and breaking them down into manageable steps, a career coach can help reignite your drive and commitment to your long-term career goals.

Career coaches can provide ongoing support and accountability to make sure you stay on track and celebrate each milestone along the way. In turn, you can increase your self-motivation over time and build your confidence as you make tangible progress in your career.

What to Look For In a Career Coach

Now that you know when you should hire a career coach, it’s time to figure out how to choose one.

There are plenty of career coaches out there, but we recommend vetting them based on these key factors:

  • Identify your needs. Reflect on whether you need career-specific advice or if something else is affecting your professional life. In some cases, a therapist might be more appropriate than a career coach.
  • Learn about their services. Find out the range of services a career coach provides. These can include resume writing, interview preparation, leadership development, and more. You might not need all their services, but make sure they do have what you need.
  • Research their background. Look into the training, certifications, and experience of the career coach you’re considering. A coach with a lot of experience and legitimate certifications can offer you more nuanced and practical advice.
  • Read testimonials. Reviews from former clients can provide insight into how good the coach is and what types of career challenges they can successfully navigate. The more impressive achievements the career coach has, the better.
  • Try sample sessions. Look for coaches that offer free initial sessions or a low-cost trial. You might need to try different coaches to gauge their compatibility with your personality and goals.
  • Consider the cost. Coaching fees vary widely, so consider what you can realistically afford. Investing in a career coach is investing in your future success, but it shouldn’t come at the cost of serious financial strain.

What to Avoid in a Career Coach

When looking to hire a career coach, you should be aware of potential red flags that can help you avoid making a choice that goes against your best interests.

Here’s what to watch out for:

  • They make vague or overpromising claims. Avoid coaches who make unrealistic or generic guarantees. Trustworthy coaches set realistic expectations and can tell you how they’ll help you achieve your career objectives; they won’t be vague about it.
  • They lack experience. There are new career coaches on the market, but someone without substantial experience in coaching or at least a background in your specific field might not provide the depth of advice you need.
  • They don’t have references or success stories. A lack of reviews can be a red flag. Good career coaches have satisfied clients who can back up their expertise.
  • They have a one-size-fits-all approach. Every career journey is unique, so every career strategy needs to be just as unique. Steer clear of career coaches who apply the same method to all of their clients instead of offering tailored guidance.
  • They use high-pressure sales tactics. If someone pressures you into making quick decisions or purchasing more sessions than you need, then that career coach might not have your best interests at heart.
  • They ignore feedback. Coaching is a two-way street. If a career coach dismisses your concerns or feedback, they’re not supporting your growth, and it’s time for you to move on.

Key Takeaways

And you’ve made it to the end of our article!

Hopefully, now you know whether hiring a career coach is the right move for you or not.

Before you go, let’s quickly recap the main points we covered:

  • Career coaches are experts who can help you navigate your career path and take strategic steps to meet your goals. They specialize in helping you make informed decisions about your career and teach you how to excel in every part of the job application process.
  • There are pros and cons to consider before hiring a career coach, such as efficiency and cost. While career coaches can speed up your job search, their rates are pricey.
  • If you’re not sure if you should hire a career coach, evaluate your situation carefully. Whether you’re confused about your next move, struggling with interviews, or just not motivated, a career coach could help you get past the challenges you’re facing.
  • Choose a career coach carefully, based on the services you need and the legitimacy of their certifications. You don’t want to risk investing your time and money in someone who doesn’t have the necessary expertise.